I've come to the conclusion that I am not particularly interested in things Fey. I don't know why. Someone close to me suggested that it is because the Fey in most books have an overall chaotic or chaotic-neutral nature (if you understand what I'm talking about, we both deserve Geek Awards; if you don't, click here). I'm not sure that is completely true, but something about fey/fairies/faeries just does not peak my interest.
This all came to light because the last three books I have finished were stories involving fey. These books (Wicked Lovely, Need, and Tithe) were not bad books, they were just not engrossing reads. What follows are my reviews for each.
Wicked Lovely by Melissa Marr:
The best aspect of this book was probably the writing style and the descriptions. The characters themselves were pretty good, but I actually found myself caring more about a secondary character rather than the MC. The plot was decent with a natural flow, but not page-turning. It centered around an almost-love-triangle, but not much action until the end.
The MC was mostly driven by her thinking she was in peril by being singled out by faeries. But since I knew, thanks to the differing points of view, that she was not, I couldn't be scared for her. This made the pressure/conflict imagined for me while it was real for the character. This is fine is doses, but for this story it lasted nearly the whole book, which took away from the plot, in my opinion.
I may or may not pick up the next book(s), which alternate MC's, as the plots sound like more of the same love-triangle-little-action business. At least I know the writing will be good.
Need by Carrie Jones:
With this book, I wasn't so crazy about the MC or the other characters because they felt kinda flat. Despite this, the premise of pixie need was interesting (though disturbing) and it had weres! I'm not even a huge fan of weres, but they were the highlight for me in this book.
The plot was jerky in places and slow, with a not-quite-formed love triangle sort-of, not-quite, almost existing. What little action that did happen was usually caused by the MC making a stupid choice, and when it wasn't, the action didn't make much sense or was too unrealistic (which, in a book about fey, is hard to pull off). Also, Need is similar to Twilight in many, many ways, which was annoying more than anything.
I may or may not pick up the next book, but if I do, it is mostly because I want to find out about the Five Courts (? - I don't have the book so I'm not sure that's what its called exactly), but the mention of the other types of fey creatures hinted at a plot line I would be interested in, though the synopsis I have seen for the next book sounds like an extension of the plot of the first, plus a new LI.
[Note: Triangles are quickly becoming my least favorite polygon.]
Tithe by Holly Black:
This was the first of the fey books I read, and the more I think about it, I like it better overall than the other two. The characters were vivid, the MC actually did stuff (as opposed to just finding out stuff) fairly early in the story. There was also action that made sense within the story, with a twist or two, plus a good ending.
The world was interesting though quite dark (scary faeries) and there were some elements I could have done without. Other than that, my only plot-qualm was the lack of explanation about the actions/motivations of the Seelie Court, and there could have been more Roiben. I wouldn't have minded that one bit.
This is another series that alternates characters for each book, and the synopsis for the book including these characters doesn't sound that enticing to me. At least there isn't a durned love triangle in this one. Wait, there was kinda one, but it wasn't really one, not quite.
*sigh*
Despite these three books being regarded quite highly in the YA world, they just didn't do it for me. Fey/fairies/faeries just don't seem to be my thing. While they are generally likable, they just don't hold my attention as other paranormal/supernatural YA books have in the past.